Tech Meridian ← LIVE FEED
PROMY MERIDIAN RU

NEWS · MODELS · #3839

Thomas Nagel, Berggruen Prize winner, rejects claims that LLMs are conscious

After receiving the $1M Berggruen Prize, philosopher Thomas Nagel told an interviewer he finds it 'ridiculous' to treat large language models as conscious, arguing consciousness depends on specific physical substrates rather than mere functional behavior; he also criticized Anthropic’s approach to Claude and warned that commercial incentives encourage misleading displays of sentience.

KEY POINTS

  1. After receiving the $1M Berggruen Prize, philosopher Thomas Nagel told an interviewer he finds it 'ridiculous' to treat large language models as conscious, arguing consciousness depends on specific physical substrates rather than mere functional behavior; he also criticized Anthropic’s approach to Claude and warned that commercial incentives encourage misleading displays of sentience.
  2. Nagel is a prominent philosopher whose public rejection of LLM consciousness could influence public understanding, academic debates, and policy conversations about how to treat and regulate advanced AI systems.
  3. ‘Just Ridiculous’: A Famed Philosopher Takes on AI Consciousness

WHY IT MATTERS

Nagel is a prominent philosopher whose public rejection of LLM consciousness could influence public understanding, academic debates, and policy conversations about how to treat and regulate advanced AI systems.

SOURCES & TIMELINE

1